Top Story: August 2, 2013

Wolves Save Bears

predator, animals, environment, ecosystem, life cycle, wolf, bear, grizzly bear, yellowstone national park, hibernation, survival, aspen tree, willow tree

By Molly Michelson

Top predators (think sharks, lions, wolves) may eat many animals within an environment, but they also keep the ecosystem in check.

This may seem counter-intuitive, but according to science writer Mary Ellen Hannibal, “We need a full complement of species on wild landscapes so that nature can fulfill its whole cycle.  It turns out that top predators—the wolf, for example—play an outsize role in keeping the whole system together.”

This was, in fact, the subject of her very excellent OpEd piece in the New York Times last fall entitled, “Why the Beaver Should Thank the Wolf.”

And scientific studies reflect this, too. A study out this week in the Journal of Animal Ecology demonstrates why the grizzly bear should also thank the wolf.

Bill Ripple, Bob Beschta, and their colleagues discovered that the return of wolves to Yellowstone National Park is beginning to bring back a key part of the diet of grizzly bears that has been missing for much of the past century—berries that help bears put on fat before going into hibernation.

“Wild fruit is typically an important part of grizzly bear diet, especially in late summer when they are trying to gain weight as rapidly as possible before winter hibernation,” Ripple says. “Berries are one part of a diverse food source that aids bear survival and reproduction, and at certain times of the year can be more than half their diet in many places in North America.”

Looking at bear scat, the researchers found that the level of berries consumed by Yellowstone grizzlies is significantly higher now that shrubs are starting to recover following the re-introduction of wolves, which have reduced over-browsing by elk herds. The berry bushes also produce flowers of value to pollinators such as butterflies, insects, and hummingbirds; food for other small and large mammals; and special benefits to birds.

When wolves were removed from Yellowstone early in the 1920s, increased browsing by elk herds caused the demise of young aspen and willow trees—a favorite food—along with many berry-producing shrubs and tall, herbaceous plants. The recovery of those trees and other food sources since the re-introduction of wolves in the 1990s has had a profound impact on the Yellowstone ecosystem, researchers say.

Hannibal points out that Beschta and Ripple didn’t set out to study wolves. In an email to Science Today, she says, “They set out to study the health of the Lamar River… But in looking for a cause to explain the degradation of the river, what they found is that super-abundant elk were eating the vegetation down to the roots on the river banks, and the vegetation wasn’t able to ‘recruit,’ or grow up strong and healthy. When wolves were reintroduced to Yellowstone, the vegetation started to recover. Beschta and Ripple and many other scientists documented this and analyzed it, and it turns out that elk change their behavior when wolves are around, and they stay on the move, which gives the vegetation time to recover.”

“Studies like this point to the need for an ecologically effective number of wolves,” Beschta says in a press release. “As we learn more about the cascading effects they have on ecosystems, the issue may be more than having just enough individual wolves so they can survive as a species. In some situations, we may wish to consider the numbers necessary to help control overbrowsing, allow tree and shrub recovery, and restore ecosystem health.”

Beschta’s and Ripple’s work is featured in Hannibal’s Spine of the Continent, a great story of conservation efforts to create wildlife corridors to protect these top predators and the ecosystems that depend on them. Look for more of these stories here in Science Today, and in an Academy exhibit, Life Connected, opening in Spring 2014.

Image: Bobisbob at en.wikipedia


  • somsai

    Inside science had a better version of this fairy tale.

    I paraphrased it as….

    1900s wolves and grizzlies all over park living on fruits and berries in harmony as in Eden.

    Elk hoards stealing berries from bears but brother wolf helped control vermin elk.

    Evil “hunters” “nab” wolves say Ripple/Beschta

    Elk force bears to eat garbage, 

    Elk oil boom clear cut trees no shade for Yogi Bear.

    Wolves cull 10% (ha ha ha) of elk, bear eat vegetarian berries with granola bars.

    Ripple genius, bears capitalist, 

    “other scientists ignorant, only I understand complex food web” says Ripple

    bear dines on trout with pine nuts, berries, morel mushrooms at same yuppie restaurant as author.

    Your article is ok, but lacks an interesting enough story line.

  • Targeran

    This somsai guy sounds like a real douche bag 

  • Jill

    John Muir said it years ago and it remains true forever: “When we try to pick out anything by itself, we find it hitched to everything else in the Universe.”

Previous Top Stories


About Science Today

Science Today is the California Academy of Sciences’ channel for current stories on cutting-edge technologies, life, Earth, space and sustainability. Content is produced in-house and is distributed throughout the museum, on the internet and through various partners. Please share your comments on what you find important in the changing world of science.